next up previous contents
Next: Theorem Up: Throwing N stones into Previous: Problem solved with a   Contents

Problem from a different perspective

We follow [28] here. We first change the way we look at the problem; we imagine now to have the $ N$ stones in a line, and to assign to each of them a number between $ 1$ and $ M$ - this number is the box the stone falls in. There are $ M^{N}$ possible distributions, each with probability $ \frac{1}{M^{N}}=M^{-N}$. We seek the probability $ p_{0}(N,M)$ of finding all cells occupied.


Let $ A_{k}$ be the event that cell number $ k$ is empty ( $ k=1,2,\cdots,n$). In this situation all $ N$ stones are placed in the remaining $ (M-1)$ cells, and this can be done in $ (M-1)^{N}$ different ways. Similarly, there are $ (M-2)^N$ arrangements, leaving two preassigned cells empty, etc. Accordingly and with $ \frac{(M-1)^N}{M^N}=(1-\frac{1}{M})^N$:

$\displaystyle p_{i}=(1-\frac{1}{M})^{N}, p_{ij}=(1-\frac{2}{M})^{N},
p_{ijk}=(1-\frac{3}{M})^{N}, \cdots
$

and hence for every $ 1 \leq \nu \leq M$

$\displaystyle S_{\nu}=\binom{M}{\nu}(1-\frac{\nu}{M})^{N}.
$

$ S_{\nu}$ is the sum of probabilities, where each arrangement with $ \nu$ cells empty appears once and only once.

We use now an important theorem proved in [28, pg 99]:



Subsections
next up previous contents
Next: Theorem Up: Throwing N stones into Previous: Problem solved with a   Contents
Tiziano Mengotti 2004-03-27